Skip to content

Oregon siting council decides on Boardman coal plant site and Wheatridge wind Friday; Carty hearing Thursday

This week in land, water, and energy across the rural West: Oregon's siting council on the Boardman coal plant site, Wheatridge wind and Carty solar, Idaho geothermal sale results, a $25 million Lower Umatilla Basin groundwater settlement, a North Dakota coal lease, and deadlines in four states.

Panoramic view of the Boardman Coal Plant, with its tall smokestack, boiler building and coal handling structures, on open grassland near Boardman, Oregon
The Boardman Coal Plant near Boardman, Ore., in 2009, before it stopped running in 2020. Photo: Tedder, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Oregon's Energy Facility Siting Council meets Thursday and Friday in Boardman, where it is scheduled to decide whether to end the state site certificate for the closed Boardman Coal Plant and whether to split the Wheatridge East wind facility's certificate, and to hold a Thursday evening hearing on solar and batteries at the Carty Generating Station. In Idaho, the Bureau of Land Management's geothermal lease sale on Tuesday brought in about $7.9 million. And Lamb Weston has agreed to pay $25 million to settle a proposed class action over groundwater in the Lower Umatilla Basin.

Dates ahead:

Oregon

Siting council in Boardman

The Energy Facility Siting Council meets at the Port of Morrow Riverfront Center, Riverfront Room, 2 Marine Drive, Boardman, starting at 5:45 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, and 8:30 a.m. Friday, Nov. 20, with online and phone access listed on the meeting agenda. Spoken public comment is taken only during the Carty hearing Thursday and the general public comment period Friday.

On Friday, the council takes up Portland General Electric's request to terminate the site certificate for the 550-megawatt Boardman Coal Plant in Morrow County, which "ceased operation in 2020." In a Nov. 6 staff report, Sarah Esterson of the Oregon Department of Energy recommends approval, finding the company "retired the Boardman Coal Plant in a manner that is protective of public health, safety and the environment." A letter from the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality says the agency "considers the groundwater monitoring program to be adequate," but also says "DEQ expects to require PGE to update the groundwater monitoring plan" for the site's coal ash landfill, that the company's wastewater permit renewal is still under review, and DEQ will keep overseeing groundwater outside the Carty site boundary.

Also Friday, the council is scheduled to make a final decision on Wheatridge Renewable Energy Facility East, about 6 miles northeast of Heppner. The amendment would split the site into two certificates, leaving the operating 200-megawatt wind facility on 67,367 acres and moving the unbuilt 100 megawatts, 37 turbines, onto a new 14,722-acre certificate, and would extend the construction deadline from May 24, 2026, to May 24, 2029. The department recommends approval. After a commenter raised concerns about restoration, weed control, erosion and runoff, the department determined on Nov. 6 that the certificate holder was out of compliance with three conditions covering erosion, maintenance and revegetation, and requested a response or corrective action plan by Nov. 16, according to the staff report. The report does not say whether a plan was submitted. The council is also set to adopt final compliance rules and a 2026 carbon dioxide offset rate.

The Carty hearing is at 6 p.m. Thursday on Portland General Electric's request to add 200 megawatts of solar on up to 860 acres, up to 200 megawatts of battery storage, and related lines and a substation at its natural gas plant southwest of Boardman, growing the site by 252 acres to about 5,249 acres, according to the staff report. The department's proposed order recommends approval with conditions, including an exception for 446 acres of arable land, 85 of them high value farmland. Written comments are due 5 p.m. Monday, Dec. 14, through the department's online comment portal. The public notice says anyone who wants the council to reject or change the order must raise the issue by then, with enough detail for the council to respond.

The council will also hear a quarterly update on the Boardman to Hemingway transmission line. As of Oct. 25, ground disturbance was "approximately 90% complete," more than 700 towers were up, and about a third of the wire was strung, with commissioning "scheduled to finish before the end of 2027," according to the staff update. The report says project work started two fires in Oregon and one in Idaho this season, and the department made findings of noncompliance over a fish passage at Powell Creek in Baker County and over the project's fire prevention plan.

Umatilla basin groundwater settlement

Lamb Weston agreed on Nov. 11 to pay $25 million into a settlement fund to resolve a proposed class action in federal court in Oregon, "subject to the U.S. District Court's approval," according to the company's filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The suit is over nitrate contamination of groundwater in the Lower Umatilla Basin. The court granted preliminary approval the same day, and the fund is meant to help homeowners pay for deeper wells, water filtration and water bills, Capital Press reported. The settlement includes no admission of liability, and Lamb Weston "continues to dispute the claims," the paper reported. The 2024 suit also named the Port of Morrow and other agribusinesses; Madison Ranches agreed to a settlement in August. A final approval hearing date for the Lamb Weston settlement had not been reported.

A gold mine near Hereford

Comments on the Bureau of Land Management's environmental assessment of the Reeds Gulch mining plan, which would mine for gold on about half of 820 acres of public land near Hereford in Baker County, are due Friday, Nov. 20, BLM said. Comments can go through the project's NEPA Register page, listed as the Reeds Gulch Placer Project, or by mail to the BLM Baker Field Office, Attn. Reeds Gulch EA, 1550 Dewey Ave., Suite A, Baker City, OR 97814.

Idaho

The Bureau of Land Management's online geothermal lease sale on Tuesday, Nov. 17, brought in $7,924,129 for 23 parcels covering about 71,400 acres in Cassia, Clark, Elmore, Owyhee, Twin Falls and Washington counties, BLM said. The agency had offered 35 parcels covering about 113,330 acres, according to its sale announcement. Parcel-by-parcel bid results were not yet posted on BLM's Idaho geothermal page as of Wednesday.

Montana and the Dakotas

Montana

The Montana Public Service Commission voted 3-2 on Nov. 10 to approve the merger of NorthWestern Energy and Black Hills Corp., the Daily Montanan reported. Vice President Jennifer Fielder, who made the motion, said evidence shows the merger will mean "tens of millions of dollars in savings" for the companies and that "those savings are savings that get passed onto the customers," and Commissioner Kirk Bushman called it "putting Humpty-Dumpty back together again," the paper reported. President Jeff Welborn, voting no, said, "I don't feel like it's a bad deal but I don't see where there's a clear benefit to advance the public's interest here," NBC Montana reported. Commissioner Randy Pinocci, who also voted no, asked, "What are we going to do about lowering the rates for the people?" the Daily Montanan reported. Conditions added by Fielder require NorthWestern to report by June 2027 on whether part of its Colstrip generation could serve Montana customers as a "potential least cost electricity supply resource," and to analyze the 370 megawatts of Colstrip shares held by Puget Sound Energy in its 2026 resource plan, according to the Daily Montanan. A written order had not been posted. The case is docket 2025.10.078.

The Montana Board of Oil and Gas Conservation meets at 2 p.m. Wednesday, Dec. 9, and holds hearings at 9 a.m. Thursday, Dec. 10, at 2535 St. Johns Ave., Billings. Its December docket includes a motion by the board itself to consider limiting approval of new temporary spacing units for horizontal wells with laterals longer than four miles in the Bakken and Three Forks in Richland, Roosevelt and Sheridan counties, "until actual production data from wells within the five previously approved spacing units becomes available and has been reviewed by the Board." The docket also lists protests among Phoenix, Continental and Kraken over each other's drilling permit applications, an aquifer exemption request for a saltwater disposal well in Richland County, and a proposed transfer of nine wells in Garfield and Rosebud counties from Cline Production to Sun Coulee LLC. Hearing details are on the board's hearing page.

Westmoreland Rosebud Mining has asked the Montana Department of Environmental Quality for a partial reclamation bond release on about 452 acres of Area A at the Rosebud Mine near Colstrip. Comments are due Friday, Nov. 20, by email to DEQCoal@mt.gov with the subject line "Rosebud Coal Mine Area A Bond Release SL18 Completeness Determination," according to the department's notice.

Objections to the Montana Water Court's interlocutory decree for Basin 43D, the Clarks Fork of the Yellowstone, are due Monday, Nov. 23, and for Basin 43Q, the Yellowstone between the Clarks Fork and the Bighorn, Tuesday, Dec. 22, according to the court's public notices.

Scoping comments on 52 parcels covering 18,345 acres proposed for a February 2027 Bureau of Land Management sale in the Montana-Dakotas region are due Friday, Nov. 27, through the project's ePlanning page, BLM said. The ePlanning page lists different figures, 60 parcels and about 18,565 acres, and older comment dates, so commenters may want to check the parcel list there. The next step is a sale notice and protest period, which BLM's National Fluid Lease Sale System listed earlier this month as starting Dec. 22.

North Dakota

The Bureau of Land Management and the Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement are reviewing Falkirk Mining Co.'s application for a federal coal lease covering about 1.89 million tons under about 208.7 acres of private land in McLean County, which could be mined through 2034, BLM said. BLM's release lists a public hearing from 3 to 5 p.m. Mountain time Wednesday, Dec. 16, at Underwood City Hall, 88 Lincoln Ave., Underwood; Underwood is on Central time, where that would be 4 to 6 p.m., so attendees may want to confirm with BLM. The Federal Register notice says comments on fair market value and maximum economic recovery must be received by Thursday, Dec. 17, while BLM's release says written comments will be accepted until Wednesday, Dec. 23; commenters may want to use the earlier date. The notice directs comments to the project's ePlanning page, which did not yet show an open comment period as of Wednesday; BLM's release also lists mail to BLM, Attn: Tessa Wallace, Solid Minerals, 5001 Southgate Dr., Billings, MT 59101.

The North Dakota Industrial Commission hears oil and gas cases at 9 a.m. Central time today and Thursday at the Oil and Gas Division, 1000 E. Calgary Ave., Bismarck, with live audio, according to its hearing dockets. Most of the roughly 90 cases are spacing, pooling and saltwater disposal requests; on Thursday, 1776 Disposals LLC asks the commission to transfer it a confiscated well in Williams County so it can be returned to injection. December hearings are Dec. 16 and 17.

South Dakota

NorthWestern Energy now estimates the construction cost of its proposed Hub City Energy Park near Aberdeen at $470 million, according to a Nov. 5 letter to the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission. The plant would have three natural gas turbines totaling about 131 megawatts gross, plus a substation, a power line and a natural gas line to the Northern Border Pipeline. The commission considers a filing fee of up to $435,000 at its Thursday meeting. A public input meeting is at 5:30 p.m. Central time Monday, Nov. 23, at the Dakota Event Center, 720 Lamont St. S, Aberdeen, and party status applications are due 5 p.m. Central time Tuesday, Dec. 1, according to the notice of application. Anyone may send written comments by mail, delivery or email; filings are in docket EL26-031.

Black Hills Power has withdrawn its notice that it would start charging interim rates on Dec. 1 for costs tied to its Lange II project, under a Nov. 16 agreement with commission staff and the South Dakota Large Customer Group. The company's notice would have added about $17.26 a month for a typical residential customer using about 600 kilowatt-hours, and the company said it had the authority to put interim rates in place without commission action, according to an objection by staff attorney Amanda Reiss. Reiss argued the state's interim rate law "does not apply to phase in rate plans," and that because the company's settled base rates would otherwise lower bills, "customers would not recognize a reduction in their bills but would instead see an increase." Under the agreement, which asks the commission to accept it and defer Thursday's hearing on the objection, the company will not seek interim rates before Feb. 1, 2027, or Lange II's in-service date, whichever is later. The case is docket EL26-024.

The state Water Management Board is set to consider Powertech (USA) Inc.'s two water permit applications for the Dewey-Burdock uranium project in Custer and Fall River counties at 10:45 a.m. Central time Wednesday, Dec. 2, in the Matthew Training Center of the Joe Foss Building, 523 E. Capitol Ave., Pierre, according to the notices for Application No. 2914-2 and Application No. 2915-2. The first would draw up to 274.2 acre-feet a year from the Inyan Kara aquifer through as many as 1,000 wells, and the second up to 253.2 acre-feet a year from the Madison aquifer through up to two wells. The deadline for petitions and comments passed Nov. 9. The board's meetings page listed no upcoming meetings as of Wednesday, so anyone planning to attend should confirm with the Department of Agriculture and Natural Resources.

Wyoming

Comments on 333 parcels covering 426,064 acres proposed for a March 2027 Bureau of Land Management lease sale in Wyoming close at 11:59 p.m. Wednesday, Nov. 25, according to the sale's ePlanning page; BLM's news release gives Thursday, Nov. 26, which is Thanksgiving, so commenters may want to use the earlier date. Scoping on 104 parcels covering about 123,166 acres, all in Laramie County, for a June 2027 sale runs through 11:59 p.m. Friday, Nov. 27, on that sale's ePlanning page. BLM's December sale of 172 parcels covering about 249,573 acres is scheduled for Wednesday, Dec. 9, BLM said; the protest period closed Oct. 28, and BLM had not posted protest decisions on the sale's ePlanning page.

Further out

The U.S. Forest Service has proposed revising its grazing rules for national forests and grasslands to "modernize grazing administration, improve clarity, codify existing policy, and expand opportunities for stewardship and access," according to the proposed rule published Nov. 12. It would set up a framework for responding to drought and wildfire, allow targeted and outcome-based grazing under temporary permits, make grazing fees consistent across the 16 contiguous Western states and the national grasslands, and add a surcharge when permittees lease livestock. Comments are due Monday, Dec. 14, at regulations.gov, docket FS-2026-0199.

Separately, the Forest Service's revised rules for objecting to projects took effect Nov. 12, according to the final rule. They set minimum comment periods of 15 days for environmental assessments and 30 days for environmental impact statements, limit objections to 15 and 30 pages, have the responsible official review objections, and move legal notices to agency websites "rather than newspapers of record or routine Federal Register publication."

Comments on the Bureau of Land Management's proposed rewrite of its land use planning rules are due Monday, Jan. 11, 2027, at regulations.gov, docket BLM-2026-0298. BLM holds an online information session at 5 p.m. Mountain time Thursday, Dec. 3.

More in Land & Water

See all

More from Bunchgrass Staff

See all