Skip to content

Would it work here? Paying off the neighbors' medical debt

A Kentucky city set aside $1 million and erased more than $31 million in residents' medical bills. What a county-funded payoff would and would not do in Oregon, Montana and the Dakotas.

Two riders on horseback moving a herd of cattle across dry grassland
Photo: Bailey Alexander / Unsplash
Published:

A Kentucky city set aside $1 million and has so far wiped out more than $31 million in residents' medical bills. Could a county in Oregon, Montana or the Dakotas do the same?

The idea is simple. A city, county or state gives money to the nonprofit Undue Medical Debt, which buys past-due medical bills in bulk from hospitals and collection agencies at a steep discount and cancels them. Nobody applies. People who qualify get a letter saying the debt is gone.

$1 million
set aside by the Lexington council in 2024
$31 million
in medical bills erased so far
15,144
residents whose debt was canceled

Lexington, Kentucky. Source: WKYT.

Lexington, Kentucky, is a recent example. Its council approved $1 million in 2024, and four rounds of relief have erased more than $31 million for 15,144 residents, an average of about $2,000 each, WKYT reported. To qualify, a resident must earn no more than four times the federal poverty level or owe medical debt equal to at least 5% of annual income. A review published this fall counted 10 states and 21 local governments that have done this since 2022, canceling $13.5 billion for 7 million people, usually at a cost of about $1 for every $100 of debt. Oregon, Montana and the Dakotas are not among them.

How much debt is here

Adults owing more than $250 in medical bills
South Dakota 17.7%
United States 8.6%
Oregon 5.2%

Average year, 2019 to 2021. Source: KFF analysis of census survey data.

South Dakota had the highest rate in the country in a KFF analysis of census survey data: 17.7% of adults owed more than $250 in medical bills in an average year from 2019 to 2021, against 8.6% nationally. Oregon, at 5.2%, was among the lowest. The survey years came before South Dakota expanded Medicaid in 2023.

Credit reports show much less, partly because credit bureaus no longer list paid medical collections or unpaid ones under $500. In August 2024, medical debt in collections appeared on the credit reports of 3.5% of consumers in Montana, 2.5% in North Dakota, 1.4% in Oregon and 1.3% in South Dakota, according to the Urban Institute. The rural districts ran higher: 4.4% in Montana's eastern congressional district against 2.7% in the western one, and 2.0% in Oregon's 2nd District, which covers Eastern Oregon, the highest in that state.

What the evidence says

83,401
people whose debt was canceled at random
$169 million
in debt erased, 2018 to 2020
No gain
on average in credit scores or mental health

A randomized study found little measurable benefit. Economists worked with the same nonprofit to cancel $169 million in debt for 83,401 randomly chosen people from 2018 to 2020 and compared them with people whose debt was not canceled. On average, relief did not improve credit scores, access to credit or mental health, and people became slightly less likely to pay other medical bills, according to a summary of the study. Credit improved modestly only for people whose debt would otherwise have shown on a credit report. The researchers concluded that debt relief alone does not address the harm done by high health care costs.

What is different here

So, would it work here?

A county or city here could cancel qualifying debt if local hospitals or collectors agree to sell it and the money is found. Whether that would noticeably improve residents' finances or health is less certain, given what the randomized study found. The first things to find out are how much eligible debt local hospitals and collectors hold and what it would cost to buy.

Who would have to act: a county commission or city council to put up the money, and the local hospital board to sell or donate the debt. A legislature could do it statewide. Lawmakers in Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota and Oregon all convene in January.


What approach from another community should we examine next?

More in Rural Services

See all

More from Bunchgrass Staff

See all